Why children were allowed to ‘plunder’ the Christmas tree

In the 19th century, some families did indeed let children ‘plunder’ the Christmas tree: they took sweets and small presents from the branches, and in some literary accounts, broke off branches and toppled the tree. This marked the end of the children’s celebration, which was originally intended to last just one evening. However, accounts of toppled trees do not establish that every family was expected to follow this practice: as the custom evolved, families increasingly kept the tree at home for several days.

What did it mean to ‘plunder’ a Christmas tree?

In the festive language of the 19th century, this meant letting children strip the tree, chiefly by removing the edible decorations and small gifts prepared for them. The Presidential Library describes the custom in precisely these terms: after the celebration, guests were given the tree with its treats. The verb should not be taken as evidence of theft or inevitable disorder in every household: the adults themselves gave permission to take the gifts.

A magazine illustration shows adults and children gathered around a decorated Christmas tree in a room.

Adults and children beside a decorated Christmas tree. Illustration from the magazine Zhivopisnoye Obozreniye, 1886. Wikimedia Commons, Zhivopisnoye Obozreniye 1886, No. 01-26 (5 Jan. — 23 June); No. 27-52 (6 July — 28 Dec.) Page 927.jpg, author: Zhivopisnoye Obozreniye Stran Sveta magazine (1872—1900,1902—1905) / Zhivopisnoye obozreniye stran sveta [Zhivopisnoye obozreniye stran sveta (Foreign Lands' Pictorial Review)]; National Library of Russia (NLR); kmv20120, licence: Public domain source

Cultural historian Elena Dushechkina, in her book ‘The Russian Christmas Tree: History, Mythology, Literature’ also cites other expressions of the period: ‘plucking the Christmas tree’ and ‘demolishing the Christmas tree’. These refer to the climax of the children’s evening, when the tree was handed over to them. The sources describe various actions side by side: pulling off a sweet, removing an ornament, breaking off a branch, toppling the trunk. It would be wrong to equate every instance of ‘plucking’ with the tree being brought down: these words covered several ways of treating the tree.

The custom is easier to understand if we distinguish between the Christmas tree as an object and the ‘Christmas tree’ as an event. Dushechkina recalls Vladimir Dal’s observation that the Russian term referred both to the decorated tree and to the children’s celebration held around it. Thus, ‘the end of the Christmas tree’ could mean the end of the evening; what happened to the trunk was part of the proceedings, but there was more to the occasion than that.

Why were there things for children to take off the branches?

The Christmas tree did more than decorate the room. Apples, gilded nuts, gingerbread and sweets formed part of its decorations and were also intended for the children. Paper ornaments and other small items that could be removed also hung from the branches. As the treats disappeared, the festive tree’s very appearance changed: its splendid fullness depended on the items waiting to be handed out.

Ethnographer Yulia Ivanova-Buchatskaya in her study of German Christmas traditions based on the Kunstkamera collections describes the early Christmas tree as a ‘gift tree’. She explains that the earliest decorations were predominantly edible: baked goods, sugar confections, fruit and nuts. After the festivities, children took them down and ate them. The German evidence shows how the custom adopted by Russian families worked in practical terms; it does not prove that every Russian household followed the German practice exactly.

Dushechkina also cites evidence from Russia of a different way of giving presents. According to an 1842 report in the magazine ‘Zvyozdochka’, presents for children had begun to be laid out beside or beneath the decorated Christmas tree, each with a note bearing the recipient’s name. Books and large toys did not have to hang from the branches. Thus, Christmas tree presents meant both objects on the tree and gifts handed out beside it. The later image of every present lying beneath the tree simplifies the history of these physical arrangements.

The account in ‘Zvyozdochka’ helps us see the change more clearly. The same 1842 report noted that parents had previously given their children Christmas presents when they came to offer their Christmas greetings on the morning of the first day of the holiday. What was new was placing the presents beside the tree and making their presentation a spectacle. The origins of the Christmas tree should therefore be distinguished from those of Christmas gift-giving: the tree changed the setting, timing and appearance of an established family custom.

A brown sugar ornament made of two rings with a purple hanging cord, against a light background.

Sugar Christmas tree ornament in the shape of two linked rings. USA, late 19th century; Cooper Hewitt collection. Wikimedia Commons, Ornament, Christmas Tree (USA), late 19th century (CH 18409235).jpg, author: Unknown artistUnknown artist, licence: Public domain source

Name tags, too, are hard to reconcile with the idea of an indiscriminate scramble for all the presents. According to N. V. Rozanova’s recollection, quoted by Dushechkina, notes were pinned to toys intended for the invited children so that the organisers knew who should receive them. Sweets could be taken freely from the branches, but adults handed out the gifts intended for particular recipients. Both practices coexisted at the same celebration, and the word ‘plundering’ describes only part of what took place.

However, not everything hanging on the Christmas tree was edible. Dushechkina describes cardboard figures, Christmas crackers, paper lanterns and items children made together with adults. In Tatyana Sukhotina-Tolstaya’s recollection, a child recognised their own cardboard creations among the decorations. For the child the tree was both a showcase for the family’s handiwork and a source of small gifts. The distinction between a handmade figure, a sweet treat and an expensive present is fundamental: one was taken from a branch, another was found beneath the tree or on a table.

In the 1840s, according to press reports collected by Dushechkina, St Petersburg confectioners began offering not only sweets but also ready-decorated Christmas trees, toys, books and cardboard novelties containing surprises. This wide range does not mean that every family bought such things. On a country estate, a fir tree might grow nearby, but, as the researcher notes, the celebration also required candles, decorations and money for presents. Having access to a tree and being able to afford the ceremony arranged around it were two different things.

How did the evening unfold before the tree was ‘plucked bare’?

The celebration at home described by Dushechkina was built around anticipation: behind closed doors, adults decorated the tree, hung sweet treats on its branches, arranged the presents and lit the candles just before the children entered. The children were greeted by a fully decorated, illuminated Christmas tree. Memoirs and literary works repeatedly describe the opening of the doors to the drawing room — a moment the adults carefully prepared.

Immediately afterwards, the children examined the tree and found their presents. Stripping the branches of their decorations was the final act, rather than the first thing done on entering the room. Adults expected the children to take time to admire their handiwork; Dushechkina also notes the parents’ disappointment when the children rushed towards the presents. Thus, even when the evening ended noisily, it followed a sequence of its own: preparation, the unveiling, play and then permission to take down the decorations.

Details survive in a letter from Tatyana Kuzminskaya to Sophia Tolstaya dated 14 December 1865, quoted by Dushechkina. A large Christmas tree was prepared for the festivities, and lanterns were painted. At Yasnaya Polyana, the tree formed part of celebrations that also included masquerades and sleigh rides. For those taking part, this was one of several Christmastide occasions, so the disappearance of sweets from the branches did not necessarily mark the end of the family’s winter gatherings.

In Tatyana Sukhotina-Tolstaya’s memoirs, the children waited in the next room while Sophia Tolstaya and her guests prepared the drawing room. When the doors opened, the girl saw a tall tree with candles and an array of small objects. Ivan Lvovich also remembered this wait. These are two perspectives from within the same family: they allow us to reconstruct its customs, but do not provide a universal picture of a nineteenth-century household.

A long table laid with a white tablecloth and tableware, bentwood chairs and portraits in the dining room of the Tolstoy House Museum.

The dining room of Leo Tolstoy’s house museum at Yasnaya Polyana. The interior as it looks today. Wikimedia Commons, Sala da pranzo a jasnaja poljana.jpg, author: Franco Visintainer, licence: CC BY-SA 3.0 source, license

As they grew older, the children gradually joined the organisers. Dushechkina writes that from around the age of twelve they could help with preparations and keep the secret from the younger children. This age is approximate and specific to the families described; what matters is the change in role. A child who had once waited for the bell to ring and the drawing-room doors to open might later place gifts on the branches for others. This is further evidence that the ‘plundering’ was part of a sequence of events carefully planned by the adults.

Is it true that Christmas trees were always knocked to the floor in the 19th century?

There is no basis for treating the toppling of the tree as an essential part of the Christmas evening’s festivities. Dushechkina includes specific accounts in which children do indeed knock the tree over and strip even its topmost branches. Another account describes the tree being stripped of every last sweet, but makes no mention of it falling. These texts attest to different ways the festivities could end; they provide no statistics on family customs.

A detailed account in the magazine ‘Zvyozdochka’ from 1842 lists nuts, apples, candles and gifts by the Christmas tree, but does not describe the tree falling. This silence does not prove that trees were never knocked over at the time: the article explained how the new celebration was organised, rather than every possible way it might end. In fictional scenes from the second half of the nineteenth century, the toppling of the tree became a dramatic finale. The differing purposes of these sources prevent us from treating a literary episode as an obligatory part of celebrations at home.

Three frequently quoted scenes are particularly easy to mistake for evidence of a single historical norm. The 1873 children’s book ‘The Christmas Tree in the Velsky Family’ depicts broken branches and a fallen tree. In a sketch by Mikhail Saltykov-Shchedrin, the Christmas tree is already lying on the floor when the children reach for the objects. A Christmas story by N. Severin likewise ends the festivities with the tree falling onto the parquet floor. These texts show that a boisterous finale was recognisable, but they cannot be treated as a sample of three ordinary households.

Could the tree’s height affect its fate?

The height of the tree affected which decorations a child could remove unaided. Dushechkina cites an account from the late 1840s of a wealthy man in St Petersburg who commissioned an artificial Christmas tree three and a half arshins tall: earrings, gemstone rings and plain bands hung from the upper branches, while flowers, sweets and fruit adorned the lower ones. Such an expensive commission was an exception, rather than the norm for all families. The account shows that adults placed objects serving different purposes even on the same Christmas tree. In the literary scene, the tree’s fall gives the children access to its top; the arrangement of the gifts does not in itself imply that knocking the tree down was customary.

When Christmas trees began to be moved from the table to the floor, people could view them from all sides, dance around them and look for familiar decorations. We should therefore avoid imagining Christmas trees of the past as objects of a single, fixed size. A memoir describing a small tree whose decorations could easily be removed while standing and a story about a tree reaching the ceiling describe different physical conditions. Comparing these conditions helps clarify the scene of ‘plucking’ the tree more than attempting to reconstruct a rule followed by all families from a single literary phrase.

A boy stands in front of a decorated Christmas tree; toys, books and presents are laid out on the carpet around him.

A boy with toys in front of a decorated Christmas tree, circa 1900. Wikimedia Commons, Small boy standing in front of a Christmas tree with his toys.jpg, author: Unknown authorUnknown author, licence: Public domain source

Dushechkina’s remarks about psychological release should be understood as her explanation of the scenario already described. The researcher does not state that nineteenth-century parents deliberately toppled the tree for the sake of their children’s mental health. Attributing such an aim to them would mean turning a later analytical term into an undocumented motive for people in the past.

Why did adults allow the evening to end this way?

In its early days, the domestic Christmas tree was often kept for just one evening. Dushechkina notes that after the festivities, the stripped tree was taken out of the drawing room, left in the courtyard or burnt in the stove. Once the treats and gifts had been removed, the family might have had no reason to keep it in the room. In this domestic setting, removing the tree’s decorations brought the ceremony prepared by the adults to a close.

The researcher also interprets the noisy finale as an emotional release after a long wait. This is her explanation of how the festivities unfolded, rather than a measured psychological effect experienced by all the young participants in the nineteenth century. The descriptions themselves show a simpler sequence: the children eagerly awaited entry to the closed drawing room and their gifts, had a chance to examine the tree, and then could take the things hung on it for them.

This freedom did not, however, mean that adult supervision disappeared entirely. In the recollections of Yasnaya Polyana cited by Dushechkina, Sophia Tolstaya and the guests handed out gingerbread, apples, nuts and sweets from the Christmas tree to the children. Here, too, the festivities ended with the removal of the edible decorations, but without a crowd toppling the tree. These same accounts show why the word ‘plundering’ cannot be taken to describe one unvarying scene.

What happened to the trunk must be distinguished from the handing out of the items hanging on it. Dushechkina cites one instance in which the decorated tree was thrown into the courtyard after being stripped, and another in which the bare fir was left on the back stairs until the caretakers removed it. In literary scenes, children sometimes topple the trunk; in the household, adults carry it away later. These are different actions, even though both take place after the children’s party.

What happened to the tree itself at the end of the celebration?

In early domestic celebrations, the end came quickly: after a single evening, the stripped Christmas tree was removed. Over the course of the nineteenth century, however, the tree was increasingly kept in the home for longer. As Dushechkina observes, families began lighting its candles again, admiring it for several days and sometimes keeping it until Epiphany. As the Christmas tree became a lasting feature of the festivities, destroying it immediately no longer made sense.

This change cannot be dated to a single year after which the ‘plundering’ disappeared. Dushechkina describes a gradual diversification of celebrations at home. Some festivities continued to end with the stripping of the tree, while others made it part of several evenings. Even the timing of the first glimpse of the Christmas tree varied: the researcher cites Alexandre Benois’s recollection that, in his elder brother’s household, the tree was presented early on the morning of 25 December, while in his own family it was unveiled on the evening of 24 December, according to the old-style calendar.

The German comparison also cautions against an overly rigid framework. Ivanova-Buchatskaya writes that edible decorations were removed on different dates in the Christmas cycle in different localities: New Year’s Day, the Feast of the Three Kings and even Candlemas. German timings cannot automatically be applied to Russian families, but they show that ‘stripping the tree’ did not necessarily mean doing so immediately after seeing it for the first time.

Three connected pale rings with holes and three dark beads against a grey background.

Christmas tree ornament made of dough in the shape of three linked rings. USA, 1850–1899. Wikimedia Commons, Ornament, Christmas Tree (USA), 1850–99 (CH 18409251).jpg, author: Unknown artistUnknown artist, licence: Public domain source

Repeated gatherings in the same home also helped prolong the life of the Christmas tree. According to Dushechkina’s research, nineteenth-century households might host a series of celebrations: first for their own children, then for the children of relatives and acquaintances, and finally for adults. The same tree remained in the house after the first evening. This was not the rule in every family: in other homes, the stripped tree was taken out immediately. The distinction matters when considering ‘plundering’: the end of the children’s party did not necessarily mark the end of all the Christmas gatherings, and the tree could remain part of the festivities for several more days.

A later example shows the limits of this pattern too. E. Skryabina recalled how, in 1905, her family was given a Christmas tree with broken branches that had already been used at the Officers’ Club. As she remembered it, her mother and brothers managed to decorate the tree again for a celebration at home. This is an account from the early 20th century, rather than evidence of a widespread 19th-century custom. It shows that even a damaged Christmas tree could be used again.

Why were trees put up for Christmas and sometimes kept until New Year?

In 19th-century Russia, a decorated tree in the home was associated primarily with Christmas on 25 December according to the Julian calendar. New Year’s Day on 1 January fell within the Christmas season. This distinction matters to the history of ‘plundering’ the tree: the first evening might be over, but winter gatherings continued. By keeping the tree, the family could light it again or gather around it on another day.

Kolomenskoye Museum-Reserve in its exhibition materials for ‘Three Centuries of the Russian Christmas Tree’, distinguishes the New Year evergreen decorations of Peter the Great’s time from the domestic Christmas tree of the 19th century. The materials also give two accounts of the decorated tree’s introduction at court: one placing it in Moscow in 1817, the other at the Anichkov Palace in St Petersburg in 1819. The disagreement over which came first does not explain the children’s ‘plucking’ of the tree, but it does caution against assuming that Peter’s calendar decree immediately created the familiar family celebration.

Dushechkina also reveals variations within the established practice. Some families opened the drawing room on Christmas Eve, others on Christmas morning. Church writers advised postponing the entertainment until the second or third day of Christmas; sometimes a child’s illness meant that the Christmas tree celebration was put off until New Year. There was therefore no single calendar date on which the family celebration ended. Taking sweets off the tree on Christmas Eve and dismantling it after a series of gatherings over the Christmas period belonged to the same tradition, but followed different schedules.

Nicholas II’s diary, excerpts from which are quoted by the Presidential Library, reveals the variety of Christmas tree celebrations at court: in 1894, the emperor recorded one in the blue drawing room, and in 1904, several on 24 December, including one for children. A palace is not representative of a typical city flat. Its example is useful in another way: the single term ‘Christmas tree’ could refer to separate gatherings with different participants, even on the same day.

Nicholas II in uniform beside Alexandra Feodorovna, who is holding a baby; their four daughters in light-coloured dresses surround them.

Nicholas II and Alexandra Feodorovna with their four daughters and the infant Alexei, circa 1904. Wikimedia Commons, 1904-1905peterhof.jpg, author: Boasson and Eggler St. Petersburg Nevsky 24., licence: Public domain source

What changed when the celebration extended beyond the family?

Children received gifts in different ways at Christmas tree celebrations in homes and public venues. The Presidential Library notes that decorated trees appeared not only in homes, but also in clubs, theatres and other venues. Dushechkina describes Christmas tree celebrations at educational and childcare institutions, where gifts were purchased with organisers’ funds or donations and presented to children after the performances. The scale of the celebration affected how gifts were handed out: presents prepared for individual children had to be allocated, rather than allowing everyone to take whatever hung from the branches.

The Tolstoy family’s recollections reveal another limitation of this simple model. Peasant children invited to Yasnaya Polyana were given treats, yet the accounts cited by Dushechkina suggest that the hosts’ children and their guests occupied different places around the Christmas tree. The source reveals a social divide within the celebration, even though everyone was ostensibly given gingerbread and nuts. It does not support a description of the Christmas gathering as an occasion when every child had the same freedom to take part.

Why did giving out presents not mean everyone could help themselves freely?

Fiction reveals particularly clearly the distinction between treats available to everyone and gifts allocated by adults. In Fyodor Dostoevsky’s short story ‘A Christmas Tree and a Wedding’, published in 1848, the children quickly strip the sweets from the tree and break the toys. But the hosts then hand out gifts separately: a wealthy girl receives an expensive doll, while the governess’s son gets a modest book. This contrast is central to the satire of the adults. The episode serves as a reminder: free access to sweets did not put everyone on an equal footing when valuable gifts were handed out.

In another satirical sketch discussed by Dushechkina, this one by Ivan Panaev, the gifts hanging on the Christmas tree are raffled off; the expensive items go to the children of high-ranking guests. Afterwards, the organisers extinguish the candles, and the young participants leave feeling dissatisfied. This is a literary portrayal of social vanity, rather than an account of every celebration. Yet it is significant for our question: a Christmas celebration could also end with a strictly controlled distribution of gifts, without children ‘storming’ the tree.

Fyodor Dostoevsky in a grey frock coat sits against a dark background, his hands clasped in his lap.

Fyodor Dostoevsky. Portrait by Vasily Perov, 1872. Wikimedia Commons, Dostoevsky 1872.jpg, author: Unknown authorUnknown author, licence: Public domain source

The scale of public celebrations changed as the custom spread. According to Dushechkina’s research, one of the first public Christmas tree celebrations was held in 1852 at the Yekateringof entertainment pavilion in St Petersburg. The building stood in the Yekateringof pleasure gardens on the outskirts of the city, where public festivities took place. This shows that the tree had moved beyond the drawing room, but tells us nothing about how that particular celebration ended. The account of children ‘plundering’ a tree cannot be applied to a public Christmas tree simply because it was part of a celebration.

Yet a decorated Christmas tree remained beyond the reach of many families. Dushechkina cites an account from 1853 by the children’s writer Lyubov Savelyeva-Rostislavich: in places far from St Petersburg and Moscow, a Christmas tree was a rarity even among landowners, who lacked either the money or a model of how the occasion was celebrated in the capitals. A fir tree could be brought from the forest, but candles, decorations and gifts were also needed. This limitation matters when assessing how widespread the practice of ‘plucking’ the tree was: descriptions of festive halls were more often preserved in places where such a celebration could be held at all.

Over time, sources become more numerous, but they do not amount to a census. The Kolomenskoye Museum notes that decorated Christmas trees were widespread in urban and country estate life in the late 19th century; Dushechkina cites accounts from Ryazan, Vyatka and Yasnaya Polyana. This geographical spread shows the custom moving beyond St Petersburg circles. It does not prove that gifts, rules for children or what happened to the tree after the festivities were the same in all these places.

A recollection by the seamstress M. I. Klyucheva, cited by Dushechkina, offers a different social perspective. At P. Ya. Malygina’s St Petersburg workshop in the 1880s, the apprentices decorated the tree together with gingerbread, apples, crackers and ornaments. The owner prepared individual gifts for her workers: boots and an apron for one, fabric for the senior seamstress, and money for the apprentices. The Christmas tree brought together a shared task and personal gifts, but the memoir does not say that the workers pulled the tree down. Nor can the absence of such a scene be taken as proof that doing so was forbidden.

A provincial club offers another documented variation. Dushechkina quotes a report in the Volzhsky Vestnik about a Christmas tree celebration and children’s dance held on 3 January 1890 in Cheboksary: the doctor S. M. Vishnevsky is named as the organiser, and each young participant was charged one rouble, raising 35 roubles in total. The newspaper report confirms the date, place and organisational arrangements; it says nothing about stripping the festive tree. An account of a public celebration cannot automatically be given the same ending as a family evening simply because both featured a tree.

How did the items left on the tree after the festivities change over time?

By the end of the 19th century, edible decorations were used alongside items that could be kept: glass baubles and cardboard figurines. The Yelets Art Museum dates the appearance of glass baubles and strings of beads on Russian Christmas trees to the middle of the century: initially imported from Europe, they later began to be made in Russia. Glass ornaments did not displace sweets and apples. They gave adults an additional task: the fragile decorations had to be taken down and stored away if the family intended to use them the following year.

The exhibition ‘Three Centuries of the Russian Christmas Tree’ at Kolomenskoye displayed decorations from different eras, figures placed beneath the tree and gifts as distinct types of objects. This distinction helps us interpret old accounts: the word ‘ornaments’ in a scene describing items being taken off the branches does not mean that everything was disposable. The term alone cannot tell us which objects went to the children, which were broken and which the adults kept.

A transparent globe containing snow-covered houses rests on a metal stand; a candle burns on the left.

A glass Christmas bauble painted with a winter landscape, displayed on a stand. Photograph taken in 2014. Wikimedia Commons, See through painted Christmas bauble on stand.jpg, author: Domaniqs, licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 source, license

Dushechkina cites a 1916 advertisement offering ready-made sets of Christmas tree decorations at various prices. It lists candles, candle holders, beads, cardboard ornaments and glittering decorations. This was already the early 20th century, and the advertisement describes a retailer’s offering, rather than how every family decorated its tree. Even so, it shows that festive decorations had become a collection of items that people bought and could keep from year to year. A household with such a collection did not have to end the evening by destroying everything on the tree.

To prolong the festivities, the tree was sometimes lit again. Dushechkina mentions families who did this on two consecutive evenings, as well as recollections of a tree kept up until Epiphany. Igor Dyakonov recalled a third lighting for his birthday in late January; Tatyana Milyutina recounted taking down the tree only after 8 February, the anniversary of her engagement. These later examples cannot be taken as the norm for the 19th century. They show that a family could decide for itself how long to keep the tree, extending its role beyond a single occasion.

What does the debate over festive safety reveal about ‘plundering’ the tree?

Criticism from doctors in the late 19th century shows that the custom of taking sweets straight from the branches persisted. According to Dushechkina’s account, doctors warned about coloured treats, lead-based wrapping paper and wax dripping from candles onto apples. These observations do not mean that every treat was dangerous. They document a specific conflict: the tree’s bright decorations sometimes made it difficult to eat safely the treats hung there for children.

The same book describes the risk of fire: trees sometimes caught fire in family homes, and electric lighting was later recommended instead of candles for Christmas trees at public celebrations. This does not prove that the practice of taking gifts off the tree was abandoned. These measures show how adults distinguished between the different aspects of the festive tree: the spectacle, the giving of gifts and the safety of those taking part. Toppling a tree with candles on it cannot be regarded as an unquestioned requirement when the organisers of children’s celebrations themselves were discussing the fire risk.

Two lit white candles on the branches of a Christmas tree; a red bauble hangs on the right.

Lit candles and a red bauble on a Christmas tree. A modern photograph. Wikimedia Commons, Weihnachtsbaum mit Kugel und Kerzen 2013.jpg, author: indeedous, licence: Attribution source

The medical note cited by Dushechkina explicitly discusses whether children should be forbidden from taking sweets off the tree because of poisonous paints. This confirms that doctors knew about the habit of eating Christmas tree decorations and regarded it as a practical concern. However, the note does not say how many trees actually fell over. The medical text provides evidence of the risks posed by the treats, literary scenes show that the boisterous finale was familiar, and memoirs describe how things were organised in individual households.

What conclusions can be drawn from the evidence, and what questions remain open?

The strongest evidence concerns the objects and activities themselves: sweets and small gifts hung from the branches, adults prepared to reveal the Christmas tree, and children received treats. Scenes featuring a toppled tree are also indisputably present in the texts examined. What remains unclear is how widespread the custom was: published memoirs and stories provide neither a record of every celebration nor the proportion of families that allowed children to break the trunk.

The distinction between the history of a ritual and the history of its depiction is particularly clear in Dushechkina’s work. She examines memoirs, newspaper reports, children’s books and Christmas stories. A memoirist may recall a single vivid incident, a writer may emphasise conflict or delight, a merchant may describe the goods, and a doctor the danger. No single genre gives a complete picture of domestic life. Comparing them yields a more accurate, if less dramatic, answer: “plucking” the tree was a familiar finale, but the form it took varied.

An account of the nineteenth-century Christmas tree therefore benefits from precise wording. We can say that children in some households stripped the tree of every last treat, and that literature even depicts it falling over. Without further documentary evidence, these instances cannot be treated as a universal custom across all social classes, towns and decades. It is this distinction between a documented action and a general rule that preserves the historical meaning of the vivid word “plundering”.

A woman shows a Christmas bauble to shoppers beside a display case of festive decorations.

Shoppers examine Christmas tree decorations at a counter in the Detsky Mir department store in Moscow, December 1953. Wikimedia Commons, History of New Year toys in Moscow 02.jpg, author: Moscow Main Archive Administration, licence: CC BY 4.0 source, license

What does the history of ‘plundering’ the tree really explain?

This custom links two changes in the history of the celebration. The first concerns the objects themselves: the early Christmas tree was decorated with gifts, some of which were intended to be taken off and eaten. The second concerns timing: a tree prepared for a single evening gradually came to be kept in the home for several days. Accounts of a boisterous finale and recollections of a tree that remained standing for days are therefore not mutually exclusive; they reflect different family practices and different stages in the development of the tradition.

You can explore the history of the Christmas tree in the home further on the tour ‘Journey into Christmas’: the bureau’s tour includes a discussion of pre-revolutionary Christmas customs, and the route leads through Manezhnaya Square, Nikolskaya Street and Red Square towards Kitay-Gorod. These locations provide a setting for exploring Moscow’s festive culture; the article does not attribute any documented instance of a Christmas tree being ‘plundered’ to any of them.

Sources

  1. E. V. Dushechkina. The Russian Christmas Tree: History, Mythology, Literature
  2. Presidential Library. Christmas Traditions in the Russian Empire
  3. Yu. V. Ivanova-Buchatskaya. German Christmas: Traditional Elements, Objects and Symbols in the Collections and Archival Materials of the MAE
  4. Kolomenskoye Museum-Reserve. Three Centuries of the Russian Christmas Tree
  5. Presidential Library. On Celebrating the New Year
  6. F. M. Dostoevsky. ‘A Christmas Tree and a Wedding’ — Russian Virtual Library
  7. G. M. Fridlender. Commentary on F. M. Dostoevsky’s ‘A Christmas Tree and a Wedding’ — Russian Virtual Library
  8. Yelets Art Museum. Antique Christmas Tree Decorations. History
  9. Radius Tour Bureau. ‘Journey into Christmas’ tour

We took a tour of Taganka designed for 12-year-old children. It was an excellent programme. We covered a great deal of ground and learnt so much. We discovered the story of Dryanaya Street and discussed the Vladimir Highway, the surrounding monasteries and churches, and the Old Believers. We now know where Korovin was born, where Stanislavsky was born and raised, where the Morozov merchant children lived, and why Arseny Morozov was considered such an outrageous figure in his day. We also discussed Solzhenitsyn, discovered where Stalin Avenue was supposed to be built, saw the bunker, walked to the Russian metochion of the Mount Athos Monastery, and learnt why the Illuzion cinema made Taganka famous. Of course, no tour would have been complete without Vysotsky and Lyubimov. We also touched briefly on Taganka Prison, although naturally we did not go there. All in all, it was an exceptionally rich and informative tour! Our guide Alexander was superb!

Tatiana September 4, 2026

Our thanks to our guide Alexander for a magnificent sightseeing tour. Alexander’s love for Moscow and its history, his wide-ranging knowledge, elegant and engaging delivery, and personal charm make the tour not merely interesting and informative, but truly delightful! Thank you, Alexander! Tatiana and Tatiana, St Petersburg

Tatiana August 18, 2026

On July 18th, we participated in the "Soul of Moscow" group tour led by Alexander. Kitay-gorod and its surroundings revealed a new side to us, and everyone thoroughly enjoyed it. Some of us began intensively studying related materials to broaden our horizons. We'll be back, and we highly recommend it! You won't regret it.

Alexander July 20, 2026

Good afternoon, on June 23rd we had a tour called " The Soul of Moscow ," led by Alexander. He's a very pleasant young man. We visited such lovely courtyards and alleys with him that we never even knew existed, and we learned so much. We really enjoyed everything, and we hope to continue our acquaintance. Alexander! Thank you! We had a great time with you, and we thoroughly enjoyed it. See you there!

Tatyana, Galina, Nadezhda June 24, 2026

This isn't my first time with Radius. This time, I took the Moscow metro . The goal was not only to admire the underground palaces but also to learn how to navigate the metro. As a resident of a region without a metro, I was a bit apprehensive and didn't understand how to navigate the metro. Of course, the internet helps, but live communication is much better. Tour guide Yulia handled this task perfectly. The information was accessible and interesting, the presentation was calm, and the communication style was very friendly. Thank you very much for the tour and the practical experience.

Julia June 20, 2026

Good afternoon! I gave the "Soul of Moscow" tour to some of the capital's guests. We were thrilled to hear our guide, Anton. It was so informative and engaging, and very warm. To say we were absolutely delighted is an understatement. It turned out to be a truly family-friendly excursion. We learned so many interesting facts. The material was presented professionally, all our questions were answered, and we saw so much. It was simply WOW! Thank you so much, Anton, he's the best!!!!! From now on, I'll only come to you, the Radius team. I highly recommend it. I promise we'll see each other again soon on other tours.

Inna May 26, 2026

Overall, the tour left a positive impression! Thanks to Alexander for the walk through the courtyards and atmospheric spots of Kitay-Gorod; we certainly wouldn't have done it on our own. The tour was comfortable, and the guide spoke confidently and calmly. One thing we personally missed: we would have liked more of the historical part, relating to ancient Moscow and the history of Kitay-Gorod. There were quite a few stories about the Soviet period and the bar scene, but for our group, this wasn't particularly relevant. We think the program could be a little more tailored to the age and interests of the group. It would also have been interesting to add more historical facts, monuments, and details about old Moscow and the area itself. That said, the tour was still interesting, and some places and churches were truly memorable. These aren't really "cons," but rather suggestions for an even more comprehensive program.

Ksenia May 25, 2026

Hello! We had a corporate group of 10 people. Our guide was Anton, and we had a tour of Bulgakov. I would like to point out the excellent organization; everything went smoothly. The managers were very accommodating to our changes in the number of participants. The bus was very comfortable. Anton is a super-engaged and motivated guide. He lives this history and is delighted to share his knowledge and create an unforgettable experience. Everything went well. I highly recommend it!

Oleg February 19, 2026

Thank you for a fascinating tour! It gave me so much food for thought to explore! Note: Review of the "Zamoskvorechye" tour with guide Maria.

Eugene December 7, 2025

I'd like to express my gratitude on behalf of our team! Thank you for keeping to our scheduled schedule despite our lack of organization. Our colleagues appreciated your preparation for the tour! It was informative. Note: Review of the "Modern Residential Complexes, Factory Past, and Avant-Garde" tour of the ZILART residential complex with guide Maria. Maria prepared and conducted a customized tour for employees of the Samolet Group of Companies development company.

Team of the Samolet Group December 7, 2025

Thank you! You have great talent. Good luck! ☺️ You're a wonderful guide! Thank you again! Note: This is a review of the corporate tour "The Heart of the Capital" with guide Maria.

Dmitriy December 7, 2025

Thank you for a wonderful day today!!)) Note: review of the excursion "The Soul of Moscow" with guide Maria

Natalia December 7, 2025

On behalf of the whole family, I want to thank you for a very informative and interesting tour! Note: This is a review of the "Palace Dungeons" tour with guide Maria.

Eugene December 7, 2025

Good afternoon! I'd like to express my gratitude and that of my guide for organizing the tour! We were very pleased. We'd like to do it again in October, but on a different route — ZIL. Note: This refers to the tour for Samolet Group developers, led by guide Maria.

Elya September 27, 2025

Thanks to Alexander for the bar tour of Baumanka ! It was fun, exciting, and we discovered so many new places! Awesome! May we reach new heights!

Kira August 9, 2025

Good afternoon! I was on a tour of Sukharevskaya Square — we went all the way to Tsvetnoy Boulevard. I didn't expect it to be so interesting! For those wondering whether to go — go for it! It truly became one of my most memorable summer memories!

Kirill August 4, 2025

Anastasia, good morning! Thank you and Masha for yesterday! The speakers are happy. The connection through the headphones was often lost, especially at the checkpoint, but that's just our current situation. You could hear if you were standing close, no more than 1.5 meters away. Colleagues have already asked for your contact information. I'd be happy to share it and look forward to another opportunity to work with you. Special thanks to the Director for the Bureau . Note: " Heart of the Capital " tour for participants of the 2025 Moscow Oncology Forum. Guides: Anastasia and Maria.

Tina July 8, 2025

We'd like to thank Anton and Alexander for leading the tour! It was fascinating to hear how the Krasnaya Presnya district developed and how Prokhorov's influence on our city's development. It was a pleasant immersion into a quiet, previously unexplored area!

Dmitriy July 8, 2025

Good afternoon, thank you so much, Anastasia. The " Uncle Gilyai " tour was fantastic. Even though we're Muscovites and know a lot about Moscow, the experience was amazing, so much new and interesting happened. We'll definitely be back.

Victoria July 8, 2025

Thank you for the " Heart of Moscow " and " Khamovniki " tours. Anton, a knowledgeable and passionate Moscow guide, gave me the tour. He's a great storyteller, intelligent, well-read, and captivating. You've truly opened up my Moscow to me! I'll definitely be back next summer to explore Moscow with you. I'll recommend your wonderful tour program to all my friends!

Julia July 1, 2025

Excursions with the Radius travel agency are always a positive experience if you choose them. We planned a tour of Zamoskvorechye on our next visit. We've worked with our guide, Anton, before. We'll definitely recommend him to everyone we know. The tour is informative, not overloaded with dates, and the information is comprehensive yet easy to understand, as it's presented in a light, narrative manner, not like a history textbook, dry and academic. Thank you for this approach. We'll definitely use the Radius agency again on our next visit to Moscow.

Tatiana June 23, 2025

Thank you so much for the tour of Zamoskvorechye . Despite the weather, it was very interesting and informative! Note: this refers to the tour with guide Anton.

Tatiana May 6, 2025

A huge thank you to Anastasia. We had a fantastic tour of the Patriki district. We learned so much. Anastasia is a true master of her craft. The tour was captivating, not at all boring, lively and interesting. Everyone was delighted. We were full of new impressions. I definitely recommend it. You won't be disappointed!

Anna May 6, 2025

We explored the Soul of Moscow with my family and Radius on my birthday. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed the walk! Anton shared so many interesting facts about the capital and its history, taking us into spiritual depths no one else had even suspected. Most of us were either born or longtime Moscow residents who spent a lot of time walking around. It was educational, heartwarming, and unforgettable. 🙂 Overall, this wasn't my first time walking around Moscow with Anton, and each time was a real adventure!

Olga May 4, 2025