Alexander Ivanov’s sketches: how the scene with Benjamin’s cup evolved

Alexander Ivanov’s sketches for the unrealised painting ‘Joseph’s Brothers Find the Cup in Benjamin’s Sack’ show how the artist was learning to build a scene with multiple figures around a moral choice. The main shift between the versions is from the cup as the focus of the incident to Judah, who is distressed by the threat to Benjamin and prepares to intercede for him. It is this exploration of people’s differing reactions, rather than a predetermined arrangement of individual figures, that links this early concept to the later ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’.

On 20 November 2026, a multimedia exhibition exploring the preparatory studies opened at the Tretyakov Gallery in Lavrushinsky Lane; it is officially scheduled to run until 6 June 2027. The display brings together painted and drawn versions, sketchbook studies and findings from technical analysis. These reveal the approaches Ivanov explored, even though the final painting was never realised.

Which moment in Joseph’s story did Ivanov choose?

Alexander Ivanov, the artist who would later paint ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’, chose to depict the discovery of a silver cup in Benjamin’s sack. The Egyptian dignitary who ordered the cup to be planted is Joseph himself: his brothers once sold him into slavery, but now fail to recognise him. The test is intended to reveal whether they are prepared to sacrifice Benjamin in the same way.

In chapter 44 of the Book of Genesis, Joseph’s steward catches up with the brothers after their departure, accuses them of stealing the cup and searches their sacks, beginning with the eldest and ending with the youngest. The cup is found in Benjamin’s sack. The brothers tear their clothes and return to the city; Judah then asks to remain as a slave in place of his younger brother. Ivanov chose the moment before this speech: the evidence has already been discovered, while the man who will plead for Benjamin is only beginning to grasp the consequences.

The preceding events help explain Judah’s gesture. During their first journey to buy grain, the brothers already recall their guilt over what they did to Joseph, unaware of who is listening. Before the second journey, Judah promises his father that he will bring Benjamin home. The discovery of the cup both revives their past guilt and threatens this new promise.

For a history painter, this is a challenging moment: the object itself is easy to depict, but its moral significance lies in what happens before and after the moment shown. The viewer must connect the open sack with the earlier betrayal, Judah’s later intercession and Joseph’s revelation of his identity, which has yet to take place. Ivanov therefore sought a composition in which the unfolding story could be read through the distances between figures, their glances and their gestures.

Why was this subject chosen for his progress submission in Rome?

The idea took shape early in Ivanov’s Italian period as a painting to demonstrate his progress as a scholarship recipient of the Society for the Encouragement of Artists. He arrived in Rome in 1830; the surviving sketches for ‘Joseph’s Brothers’ date from 1831–1833. After studying monuments and copying the Old Masters, scholarship recipients were expected to produce an original historical composition.

Self-portrait of Alexander Ivanov: the artist, wearing a beret and a dark blue uniform, sits turned slightly to one side against a blank sheet.

Alexander Ivanov. ‘Self-Portrait’, 1828. Oil on paper. Tretyakov Gallery. Wikimedia Commons, Alexander Andreyevich Ivanov, Self-Portrait, 1828, Tretyakov Gallery Zh-491.jpg, artist: Alexander Ivanov, licence: Public domain source

In Rome, Ivanov copied Michelangelo’s fresco ‘The Creation of Adam’ and explored subjects for his own paintings. Drawing on the artist’s letters, Svetlana Stepanova shows that, alongside the story of the cup, he was considering episodes involving David and Saul and ‘The Choosing of David’. Ivanov still intended to test his initial compositions against studies from life: for him, a successful drawing was no reason to move straight to a large canvas.

In one of his letters, he compared the story of the cup with the subject of ‘David Comforting Saul’. The latter seemed more significant to him, but the former offered greater scope for studying the nude. His choice was shaped both by the meaning of the episode and by the practical scope for developing the figures.

Before arriving in Rome, Ivanov had already explored the story of Joseph, painting ‘Joseph Interpreting the Dreams of the Cupbearer and the Baker Imprisoned with Him’ during his studies in St Petersburg. In that work, he contrasted the two prisoners’ reactions to the predictions they had heard; in the subject he explored in Rome, the task became more complex, as he had to bring several brothers, their accusers and Benjamin together in a single space.

Joseph stands between two prisoners and points upwards; one has moved closer to him, while the other recoils as he sits on the dungeon floor.

Alexander Ivanov. ‘Joseph Interpreting the Dreams of the Cupbearer and the Baker Imprisoned with Him’, 1827. Wikimedia Commons, Alexandr Ivanov 025.jpg, artist: Alexander Ivanov, licence: Public domain source

What changes from one sketch to the next?

The Tretyakov Gallery reports that its collection holds four painted studies, more than ten drawn variants and around twenty sketchbook drawings. A 2006 article by Lyudmila Markina lists three works in oil; the source does not explain the discrepancy. These works vary in medium and degree of finish, so they cannot be treated as a simple sequence of successive ‘corrections’.

Technical examination of the painted variants revealed changes made by the artist within the images themselves: earlier details were replaced with new ones. This process of exploration is evident both across the individual sheets and within the layers of a single study.

Two approaches to the same scene

The art historian Mikhail Alpatov made a detailed comparison of two oil studies that Ivanov called the ‘first’ and ‘second’. In Alpatov’s view, they were probably created at around the same time, so the numbering does not indicate a straightforward progression from a weaker version to a definitive one. The main differences lie in the number of figures and the focal point for the viewer.

The second study is wider and more crowded: Alpatov counts eight figures. The cup lies on the ground in the centre, the young men react to its discovery, Benjamin rushes towards Judah, and the Egyptian reaches towards the youngest brother. This arrangement makes it clearer who faces enslavement, but divides the viewer’s attention between several gestures.

The first study contains six figures; the other brothers recede into the background, while the main emotional emphasis falls on Judah, who is tearing his clothes. The calm Egyptian stands in contrast to him. The cup remains the cause of the conflict, yet the viewer’s gaze lingers on the man who must make a choice.

An oil sketch: a man in white tears open his clothing at the chest, with a child and several adults standing nearby; sacks lie in the foreground, and other figures are visible in the background.

Alexander Ivanov. ‘Joseph’s Brothers Find the Cup in Benjamin’s Sack’, sketch, 1831–1833. At the centre of the composition is a figure tearing his clothes. Wikimedia Commons, Alexandr Ivanov 050.JPG, artist: Alexander Ivanov, licence: Public domain source

Ivanov explored two ways of clarifying the episode: to make the connection between the discovery and the threat to Benjamin explicit, or to centre the scene on Judah’s despair. The first makes the action clearer; the second gives the emotional experience a stronger focus. The artist developed neither approach into a large-scale painting.

Alpatov also notes a less obvious change: after revisions to the first sketch, the mountain peak was positioned above Judah’s head. The landscape’s contour gives the central figure greater prominence, although the sources provide no grounds for attributing any particular symbolic meaning to it.

Judah’s future role as an intercessor

In a letter about the scene with the cup, Ivanov distinguished the participants’ characters: Judah tears his clothes in despair, another figure reacts more calmly, and the Egyptian steward maintains his composure; the gesture draws on the account in Genesis, in which all the brothers tear their clothes after the evidence is discovered. The artist concentrated the most intense emotion in the figure of the man who would later plead on his brother’s behalf, thus singling him out in advance as the central character.

A separate study of Judah’s head survives among the preparatory works; Stepanova identifies Laocoön as a reference for depicting extreme suffering, while Alpatov cites Andrey Ivanov’s advice to bring the figure closer to this model. The concern here is the rendering of form — the tension in the face and body — rather than copying the ancient sculpture or its subject.

Close-up of a marble figure: the bearded head is thrown back, one arm is bent and raised, and the chest and shoulders are tense.

Laocoön’s face and taut torso — a detail of the sculptural group ‘Laocoön and His Sons’ in the Vatican Museums. Wikimedia Commons, Face of Laocoon in Vatican.JPG, author: Livioandronico2013, licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 source, license

What advice did Ivanov receive from the Roman masters and his father?

Ivanov discussed the composition with his father, the history painter Andrey Ivanov, and showed his sketches to masters working in Rome, including Johann Overbeck and Bertel Thorvaldsen. The Tretyakov Gallery’s official announcement confirms these consultations, while letters and art-historical analysis allow us to reconstruct the points of debate.

According to Alpatov, Thorvaldsen preferred the first oil sketch for its unity of moment. Vincenzo Camuccini also considered it stronger, but criticised the gaps between the figures and advised making their emotions more vivid. Ivanov’s fellow artists, by contrast, favoured the second version: the Egyptian’s hand reaching towards Benjamin conveyed the danger more clearly. Those consulted were assessing different qualities — the coherence of the scene, the clarity of the action and the expressiveness of the gesture.

In August 1831, Ivanov wrote to the Society for the Encouragement of Artists that he could not decide which version was better and sent both. His father also preferred the first, but suggested changes to Judah, Benjamin’s gaze and the costumes; in St Petersburg, the positioning of the figure beside the sack was discussed. These comments show that the sketches were still works in progress: approval of the concept did not mean that the composition had been resolved.

The advice on costumes concerned historical authenticity. Alpatov quotes a note by Ivanov on the need to study Egyptian history, dress and customs. The 19th-century artist combined this knowledge with models drawn from classical antiquity and painting; this was not an archaeological reconstruction in the modern sense.

Why was the full-scale painting never realised?

The documents offer no single, definitive reason why the project was abandoned. The artist repeatedly reworked the sketches but never painted the large canvas; by 1833, he had already formulated the concept for ‘The Appearance of the Messiah to the People’. Overbeck regarded the episode of the cup as merely a fragment of a vast biblical narrative, whereas Andrey Ivanov saw its discovery as a crucial turning point in the action.

Mary Magdalene, dressed in reddish-brown robes, kneels on the left and reaches towards Christ, who is draped in white.

Alexander Ivanov. ‘Christ’s Appearance to Mary Magdalene after the Resurrection’, 1835. Mary reaches towards Christ, who stops her with a gesture of his hand. Wikimedia Commons, Alexander Ivanov — Christ's Appearance to Mary Magdalene after the Resurrection — Google Art Project.jpg, artist: Alexander Andreyevich Ivanov (1806 — 1858) — Painter (Russian) Born in Russia, Moscow. Died in Russia, St.Petersburg., licence: Public domain source

Lyudmila Markina draws attention to the inherent complexity of the chosen moment. Without knowing the preceding events, viewers will not immediately understand why the brothers are distraught or what the accuser is concealing; trying to convey this through gestures risked theatricality. This is the art historian’s interpretation, rather than a statement by Ivanov identifying the sole reason for abandoning the project.

Alpatov describes the same problem in terms of two compositional focal points. Giving greater prominence to the cup pushes the psychological relationships into the background. Making Judah’s reaction the focal point makes the visible cause of the anxiety less prominent. The unrealised painting is valuable precisely because it leaves this choice open: the different versions reveal which solutions Ivanov explored and what he sacrificed in each.

How are the sketches connected to ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’?

The Tretyakov Gallery links Ivanov’s work on the episode involving the cup to his subsequent exploration of the composition of ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’: the experience he gained and certain motifs of form and movement carried through into his work on his principal artistic project. The museum does not identify any directly borrowed figures or gestures, so it is more accurate to speak of the development of his approach to composing a scene with multiple figures.

The sketches for ‘Joseph’s Brothers’ date from 1831–1833. By 1833, Ivanov had already written to the Society for the Encouragement of Artists about his intention to depict the appearance of the Messiah before the people; he was also working on ‘The Appearance of Christ to Mary Magdalene’. The transition from one artistic project to the other was a prolonged exploration rather than an immediate change of subject.

In ‘Joseph’s Brothers’, the discovery of an object and an accusation set the action in motion. In ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’, John the Baptist announces Christ’s arrival to the people by the River Jordan, and the various figures respond with hope, doubt and joy. Both works pose the same challenge: to arrange differing reactions around a single event; what differs is the breadth of meaning and the structure of the event itself.

An early sketch for ‘The Appearance’: the same method of testing ideas

The Russian Museum holds an oil sketch for ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’, dated 1834 and measuring 60.5 by 90.5 centimetres. In November 1834, Ivanov reported showing his new work to Thorvaldsen, Overbeck, Peter Cornelius and Camuccini. Judging by the nature of the recorded comments, the museum suggests that this was the work the artists discussed; that identification remains an attribution.

A woman with dark hair tied back looks to the right; she is dressed in brown.

Alexander Ivanov. ‘Female Head Turned in the Pose of John the Baptist’ — a preparatory study for ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’. Wikimedia Commons, Alexander Ivanov Female head the attitude of St John the Baptist gtg.jpg, artist: Alexander Ivanov, licence: Public domain source

His colleagues criticised the overly dominant landscape, the positioning of the figures on the right and the turn of John the Baptist’s head towards the viewer. The issue under discussion is familiar from the story of the bowl: Ivanov was once again examining whether one element overshadowed the others and whether the relationships within the multi-figure composition were clear.

The large sketch for ‘The Appearance of Christ to the People’ in the Russian Museum measures 172 by 247 centimetres. The catalogue note states that Ivanov originally envisaged a painting on this scale before expanding his conception. Between the initial arrangement of figures in 1834 and the monumental canvas came numerous trials and revisions — the same working method is already evident in the early story of the bowl.

How can comparing the versions reveal the artist’s working process?

It is more useful to compare the sketches by how each addresses the same challenge than by how ‘beautiful’ it is. Three steps help you find your way among the many figures:

  1. First, find the cup and the open sack: they explain why the action has come to a halt.
  2. Then trace the distance between Benjamin, the Egyptian and Judah: this reveals how much danger the youngest brother faces.
  3. Finally, compare the gestures of the other figures and decide whether they form a single focal group or several competing groups.

Kultura.RF distinguishes between a sketch as a preliminary compositional design and a study made from life. Within Ivanov’s body of work, drawings are particularly useful for comparing the arrangement of figures, paintings for observing colour and light, while technical imaging reveals hidden revisions. The biblical text explains the meaning of the event, and the correspondence the artist’s intention, but a figure’s position must be described with reference to the specific sheet.

The history of the collection shows that the word ‘final’ cannot be taken literally: in a letter to Pavel Tretyakov dated 12 February 1876, the artist’s brother Sergei Ivanov used it to describe the sketch for ‘Joseph and His Brothers’ among the works intended for the collection. The description refers to the work acquired by the museum; no large-scale painting existed.

Two female visitors stand before Ivanov’s large painting ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’; figures by the shore and a distant landscape are visible.

Women visitors viewing Alexander Ivanov’s ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’ at the Tretyakov Gallery.

How does this early project change our understanding of Ivanov?

The history of ‘Joseph’s Brothers’ challenges the idea that a large painting is the product of a single flash of inspiration. Ivanov weighed clarity of action against emotional intensity, compared the advice he received, reworked details and ultimately abandoned the composition he had spent several years developing. Its connection with ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’ lies above all in this disciplined search: the event must be understood through different human responses.

The Tretyakov Gallery in Lavrushinsky Lane is included on the route offered by the ‘Zamoskvorechye’ tour Radius Tour Bureau from Ordynka to Pyatnitskaya. This city walk places the museum in the context of its neighbourhood; a visit to the multimedia project needs to be planned separately.

Sources

  1. Tretyakov Gallery: ‘Alexander Ivanov. Working on the Sketches for “Joseph’s Brothers Find the Cup in Benjamin’s Sack”’
  2. Lyudmila Markina. Alexander Ivanov. Marking the 200th Anniversary of His Birth
  3. Russian Museum: ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’. Large Sketch
  4. Book of Genesis, Chapter 44. Russian Synodal Translation
  5. The Tretyakov Gallery: The Building on Lavrushinsky Lane
  6. Radius Tour Bureau: ‘Zamoskvorechye’ Tour
  7. Svetlana Stepanova. Joseph’s Brothers and the Silver Cup
  8. Mikhail Alpatov. Alexander Andreyevich Ivanov. Life and Work
  9. Russian Museum: early sketch for ‘The Appearance of Christ Before the People’ (1834)
  10. The Tretyakov Gallery Magazine: Sergei Ivanov — in the Shadow of His Great Brother
  11. The Book of Genesis, Chapter 42. Russian Synodal Translation
  12. The Book of Genesis, Chapter 43. Russian Synodal Translation
  13. The Book of Genesis, Chapter 45. Russian Synodal Translation
  14. Culture.ru: the meaning of the word ‘sketch’
  15. Vatican Museums: Michelangelo’s ‘The Creation of Adam’

We took a tour of Taganka designed for 12-year-old children. It was an excellent programme. We covered a great deal of ground and learnt so much. We discovered the story of Dryanaya Street and discussed the Vladimir Highway, the surrounding monasteries and churches, and the Old Believers. We now know where Korovin was born, where Stanislavsky was born and raised, where the Morozov merchant children lived, and why Arseny Morozov was considered such an outrageous figure in his day. We also discussed Solzhenitsyn, discovered where Stalin Avenue was supposed to be built, saw the bunker, walked to the Russian metochion of the Mount Athos Monastery, and learnt why the Illuzion cinema made Taganka famous. Of course, no tour would have been complete without Vysotsky and Lyubimov. We also touched briefly on Taganka Prison, although naturally we did not go there. All in all, it was an exceptionally rich and informative tour! Our guide Alexander was superb!

Tatiana September 4, 2026

Our thanks to our guide Alexander for a magnificent sightseeing tour. Alexander’s love for Moscow and its history, his wide-ranging knowledge, elegant and engaging delivery, and personal charm make the tour not merely interesting and informative, but truly delightful! Thank you, Alexander! Tatiana and Tatiana, St Petersburg

Tatiana August 18, 2026

On July 18th, we participated in the "Soul of Moscow" group tour led by Alexander. Kitay-gorod and its surroundings revealed a new side to us, and everyone thoroughly enjoyed it. Some of us began intensively studying related materials to broaden our horizons. We'll be back, and we highly recommend it! You won't regret it.

Alexander July 20, 2026

Good afternoon, on June 23rd we had a tour called " The Soul of Moscow ," led by Alexander. He's a very pleasant young man. We visited such lovely courtyards and alleys with him that we never even knew existed, and we learned so much. We really enjoyed everything, and we hope to continue our acquaintance. Alexander! Thank you! We had a great time with you, and we thoroughly enjoyed it. See you there!

Tatyana, Galina, Nadezhda June 24, 2026

This isn't my first time with Radius. This time, I took the Moscow metro . The goal was not only to admire the underground palaces but also to learn how to navigate the metro. As a resident of a region without a metro, I was a bit apprehensive and didn't understand how to navigate the metro. Of course, the internet helps, but live communication is much better. Tour guide Yulia handled this task perfectly. The information was accessible and interesting, the presentation was calm, and the communication style was very friendly. Thank you very much for the tour and the practical experience.

Julia June 20, 2026

Good afternoon! I gave the "Soul of Moscow" tour to some of the capital's guests. We were thrilled to hear our guide, Anton. It was so informative and engaging, and very warm. To say we were absolutely delighted is an understatement. It turned out to be a truly family-friendly excursion. We learned so many interesting facts. The material was presented professionally, all our questions were answered, and we saw so much. It was simply WOW! Thank you so much, Anton, he's the best!!!!! From now on, I'll only come to you, the Radius team. I highly recommend it. I promise we'll see each other again soon on other tours.

Inna May 26, 2026

Overall, the tour left a positive impression! Thanks to Alexander for the walk through the courtyards and atmospheric spots of Kitay-Gorod; we certainly wouldn't have done it on our own. The tour was comfortable, and the guide spoke confidently and calmly. One thing we personally missed: we would have liked more of the historical part, relating to ancient Moscow and the history of Kitay-Gorod. There were quite a few stories about the Soviet period and the bar scene, but for our group, this wasn't particularly relevant. We think the program could be a little more tailored to the age and interests of the group. It would also have been interesting to add more historical facts, monuments, and details about old Moscow and the area itself. That said, the tour was still interesting, and some places and churches were truly memorable. These aren't really "cons," but rather suggestions for an even more comprehensive program.

Ksenia May 25, 2026

Hello! We had a corporate group of 10 people. Our guide was Anton, and we had a tour of Bulgakov. I would like to point out the excellent organization; everything went smoothly. The managers were very accommodating to our changes in the number of participants. The bus was very comfortable. Anton is a super-engaged and motivated guide. He lives this history and is delighted to share his knowledge and create an unforgettable experience. Everything went well. I highly recommend it!

Oleg February 19, 2026

Thank you for a fascinating tour! It gave me so much food for thought to explore! Note: Review of the "Zamoskvorechye" tour with guide Maria.

Eugene December 7, 2025

I'd like to express my gratitude on behalf of our team! Thank you for keeping to our scheduled schedule despite our lack of organization. Our colleagues appreciated your preparation for the tour! It was informative. Note: Review of the "Modern Residential Complexes, Factory Past, and Avant-Garde" tour of the ZILART residential complex with guide Maria. Maria prepared and conducted a customized tour for employees of the Samolet Group of Companies development company.

Team of the Samolet Group December 7, 2025

Thank you! You have great talent. Good luck! ☺️ You're a wonderful guide! Thank you again! Note: This is a review of the corporate tour "The Heart of the Capital" with guide Maria.

Dmitriy December 7, 2025

Thank you for a wonderful day today!!)) Note: review of the excursion "The Soul of Moscow" with guide Maria

Natalia December 7, 2025

On behalf of the whole family, I want to thank you for a very informative and interesting tour! Note: This is a review of the "Palace Dungeons" tour with guide Maria.

Eugene December 7, 2025

Good afternoon! I'd like to express my gratitude and that of my guide for organizing the tour! We were very pleased. We'd like to do it again in October, but on a different route — ZIL. Note: This refers to the tour for Samolet Group developers, led by guide Maria.

Elya September 27, 2025

Thanks to Alexander for the bar tour of Baumanka ! It was fun, exciting, and we discovered so many new places! Awesome! May we reach new heights!

Kira August 9, 2025

Good afternoon! I was on a tour of Sukharevskaya Square — we went all the way to Tsvetnoy Boulevard. I didn't expect it to be so interesting! For those wondering whether to go — go for it! It truly became one of my most memorable summer memories!

Kirill August 4, 2025

Anastasia, good morning! Thank you and Masha for yesterday! The speakers are happy. The connection through the headphones was often lost, especially at the checkpoint, but that's just our current situation. You could hear if you were standing close, no more than 1.5 meters away. Colleagues have already asked for your contact information. I'd be happy to share it and look forward to another opportunity to work with you. Special thanks to the Director for the Bureau . Note: " Heart of the Capital " tour for participants of the 2025 Moscow Oncology Forum. Guides: Anastasia and Maria.

Tina July 8, 2025

We'd like to thank Anton and Alexander for leading the tour! It was fascinating to hear how the Krasnaya Presnya district developed and how Prokhorov's influence on our city's development. It was a pleasant immersion into a quiet, previously unexplored area!

Dmitriy July 8, 2025

Good afternoon, thank you so much, Anastasia. The " Uncle Gilyai " tour was fantastic. Even though we're Muscovites and know a lot about Moscow, the experience was amazing, so much new and interesting happened. We'll definitely be back.

Victoria July 8, 2025

Thank you for the " Heart of Moscow " and " Khamovniki " tours. Anton, a knowledgeable and passionate Moscow guide, gave me the tour. He's a great storyteller, intelligent, well-read, and captivating. You've truly opened up my Moscow to me! I'll definitely be back next summer to explore Moscow with you. I'll recommend your wonderful tour program to all my friends!

Julia July 1, 2025

Excursions with the Radius travel agency are always a positive experience if you choose them. We planned a tour of Zamoskvorechye on our next visit. We've worked with our guide, Anton, before. We'll definitely recommend him to everyone we know. The tour is informative, not overloaded with dates, and the information is comprehensive yet easy to understand, as it's presented in a light, narrative manner, not like a history textbook, dry and academic. Thank you for this approach. We'll definitely use the Radius agency again on our next visit to Moscow.

Tatiana June 23, 2025

Thank you so much for the tour of Zamoskvorechye . Despite the weather, it was very interesting and informative! Note: this refers to the tour with guide Anton.

Tatiana May 6, 2025

A huge thank you to Anastasia. We had a fantastic tour of the Patriki district. We learned so much. Anastasia is a true master of her craft. The tour was captivating, not at all boring, lively and interesting. Everyone was delighted. We were full of new impressions. I definitely recommend it. You won't be disappointed!

Anna May 6, 2025

We explored the Soul of Moscow with my family and Radius on my birthday. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed the walk! Anton shared so many interesting facts about the capital and its history, taking us into spiritual depths no one else had even suspected. Most of us were either born or longtime Moscow residents who spent a lot of time walking around. It was educational, heartwarming, and unforgettable. 🙂 Overall, this wasn't my first time walking around Moscow with Anton, and each time was a real adventure!

Olga May 4, 2025